Managing vs. Letting Agent: What Works Best Under the Renters’ Rights Bill?
With the Renters’ Rights Bill set to shake up the UK’s private rental sector in 2025, many landlords face a critical question: Should you continue self-managing, or hand the reins to a professional agent?
What to Expect from the Renters’ Rights Bill
By eliminating "no-fault" (Section 21) evictions, banning fixed-term tenancies, and enforcing tougher living standards like the Decent Homes Standard and Awaab’s Law, the Bill introduces a wave of new compliance requirements for landlords and agents alike (GOV.UK, theindependentlandlord.com, MoneyWeek). It also mandates registration with a new PRS database and Ombudsman (GOV.UK, Whitegates).
The Self-Management Option: Still Possible—But Riskier
If you choose to self-manage:
You're responsible for compliance with new standards for hazards, discrimination, pet requests, and tenant documentation (GOV.UK, Savills).
Non-compliance could land you with civil penalties of up to £7,000, especially under the stricter enforcement outlined in the Bill (MoneyWeek, GOV.UK).
Experts warn that the increased legal complexity places self-managing landlords at significantly higher risk (landlordzone.co.uk, Estate Agent Today).
The Letting Agent Path: Greater Compliance, Lower Stress
Using a regulated agent brings distinct advantages:
Many are already part of mandatory redress and compliance schemes, helping ensure legal adherence (e.g. deposit protection, renewal notices) (Whitegates, Letting Agent Today).
Agents must adhere to landlord-tenant dispute protocols, including implementing the Ombudsman process and using standard inventories and records (The Times, Letting Agent Today).
As compliance responsibilities grow, agencies offering expert guidance on the new legislation are becoming invaluable to landlords (Estate Agent Today).
Summary Comparison
Approach Self-Manage Use Letting Agent Control High autonomy, but increasing risk Shared responsibility, more robust protection Compliance DIY—prone to errors and penalties Expertise in regulatory obligations Cost Lower fees, higher personal time investment Agent fees, but time and risk are lowered Convenience Full involvement required Efficient handling of complex tasks.
Final Takeaway
The Renters’ Rights Bill is not just more regulation—it’s a regulatory overhaul that significantly raises the stakes. For many landlords, especially those managing smaller portfolios or lacking legal resources, partnering with a qualified letting agent isn’t just prudent—it’s increasingly essential.
Agents offer peace of mind in navigating:
Redress and Ombudsman compliance
Dispute resolution protocols
Documentation management and responsiveness
If you're evaluating property management options ahead of the reforms, SHPC Limited can guide you through tailored structures—be it self-management with safeguards or transitioning to agent-led strategies.
GET IN TOUCH WITH US
